The email marketing agency that keeps the traffic your ads already paid for

First Spark runs email and SMS for D2C and CPG brands. We raise the share of visitors who sign up, build the flows and campaigns that sell to them, and show you which ad channel brings the subscribers who buy.

Email marketing from $2,500 a month. Your Klaviyo subscription is paid to Klaviyo directly.

Komuso static ad: 'Anxiety is normal. Breathing smarter can help.' above four breathing necklaces. The headline is circled in red marker with the note: the ad makes a promise.

Komuso · signup form opt-in rate

3x the signups for every form view

the form keeps it

Every signup enters the flows, tagged by opt-in source

  1. Welcome
  2. Browse
  3. Cart
  4. Post-purchase
  5. Win-back

MetaGoogleTikTokOrganic

the flows sell it

"First Spark is like a creative director meets CFO. They took over our creative production and media buying strategy and 10x'd our business in 2 years."

Todd Steinberg, Founder and CEO, Komuso

3x opt-in rate

Komuso, from 2% to 6% of signup form views.

$65K email revenue a month

Komuso, up from $20K a month.

2.7x opt-in rate

Kumori, from 4% to 10.8% of signup form views.

Komuso Kumori Muddy Bites GoNanas Copper Moon Coffee EBOOST Hammerhead

Why most of your paid traffic leaves without a trace

You pay for every click. Most of those visitors don't buy on the first visit, and most of them don't leave an email either. It's usually one of three things.

  1. Most visitors never buy and never sign up

    Klaviyo tells brands to aim for a popup opt-in rate of about 3% of form views. Even at that rate, 97 of every 100 visitors who see the form leave with nothing you can follow up on. On paid traffic, you paid for every one of them.

  2. One popup for every visitor

    The same 10%-off form greets someone who clicked a founder video and someone who searched your brand name. A form that continues the ad's promise gives the visitor a reason to sign up.

  3. Paid and email keep separate scoreboards

    Meta claims the sale, Klaviyo claims the same sale, and nobody can say which channel brings the subscribers who become customers. So the budget never moves toward them.

Example subscriber profile

Signed up
Mobile popup, product page
Opt-in source
Meta, prospecting
Ad
Founder video
Welcome flow
Founder story version
Orders since signup
2

every signup keeps its source

We report email revenue by opt-in source

Every subscriber carries the channel, campaign and ad that brought them. Instead of one email revenue number, you see which sources bring the subscribers who buy, and the paid budget can follow them. The profile above is an illustration of what we tag.

Want a quick read on how much paid traffic you keep? Try the Capture Rate calculator.

What our email marketing includes

Everything that decides whether a visitor becomes a subscriber and a subscriber becomes revenue, from the first form test to the weekly send plan.

An opt-in target for every form

We measure each form's opt-in rate, signups per form view, split by paid, organic and direct traffic, and set a target for each. Klaviyo's 3% is the floor, not the goal.

Signup forms built for paid traffic

Offers, two-step email and SMS forms, quizzes and landing-page signups, matched to the ads that send the traffic and tested every month.

Flows that sell while you sleep

Welcome, browse, cart and checkout abandonment, post-purchase, replenishment or subscription, win-back and sunset. Each one is written for the buyer it reaches, not copied from a template.

A campaign calendar with a reason for every send

Segmented sends tied to launches, promotions and the paid calendar, at a cadence your list can take without burning out.

Deliverability and list health

SPF, DKIM and DMARC set up right, Gmail and Yahoo sender rules met, engaged segments and sunsetting, so the inbox keeps taking your mail.

Reporting that ties email to paid

Flows against campaigns, revenue per subscriber and email revenue by opt-in source, with the reason behind each change.

Paid and email, run as one system

Most brands hire one team to buy traffic and another to email it, and nobody owns the handoff between them. In the Spark Growth System, one team runs both, so each turn of the loop is planned with what the last one taught.

  1. 1The ad makes a promise. One reason to buy, in the ad and on the page.
  2. 2The form keeps it. The signup offer continues the same promise.
  3. 3Flows and campaigns sell. The welcome picks up where the ad left off.
  4. 4Revenue is tagged by source. Each sale traces back to the ad that earned the signup.
  5. 5Budget follows the buyers. Paid spend moves to the sources that bring subscribers who buy.

and around again, with better data each time

Source tagging

The tracking tags on your ads carry through to each subscriber's profile, so every subscriber has an origin you can report on.

Budget calls

Channels are judged on the buyers they bring plus the subscribers who buy later, not only on the ROAS in the ad platform.

Audiences

Subscriber and customer lists sync to Meta, Google and TikTok, to keep existing buyers out of prospecting and to build lookalikes from the best ones.

Messaging

The ad angle that earned the click opens the welcome flow, and the subject lines that win in email brief the next round of ads.

Running paid with us too? See our Meta ads, Google Ads and performance creative work.

Your first 90 days

We start where the money leaks first: the forms and the welcome flow. If your email program is brand new, month one is building instead of rebuilding.

  1. Month 1: capture. Audit the account, the forms and deliverability, tag every signup with its source, and rebuild the main signup forms and the welcome flow.

  2. Month 2: flows. Launch the abandonment, post-purchase and win-back flows, and start testing forms against each other.

  3. Month 3: campaigns and scale. Set the campaign calendar and segments, start reporting revenue by opt-in source, and feed the first budget calls back to paid.

Email results for D2C and CPG brands

Opt-in rate here means signups per signup form view, the way Klaviyo measures it. More on our client results page. Selling in retail? See how we work as a CPG marketing agency.

Komuso

Opt-in rate from 2% to 6%

Email revenue from $20K to $65K a month

Three times as many signups for every form view, and more than three times the email revenue each month.

Kumori

Opt-in rate from 4% to 10.8%

Already above Klaviyo's 3% guidance when we started. Now 2.7 times higher.

Email marketing starts from $2,500 a month

Three packages, priced on how much we send, how many forms we test and how closely email runs with your paid ads. You'll see the scope before you sign.

Foundation

$2,500 a month

For brands starting or rebuilding email.

  • Your main signup popup rebuilt for desktop and mobile, with one form test a month.
  • Four core flows: welcome, cart and checkout abandonment, browse abandonment and post-purchase.
  • Four campaigns a month.
  • Every signup tagged with its opt-in source.
  • A monthly report on opt-in rate by form, flows vs campaigns and list health.

Where most brands start

Growth

$5,000 a month

For brands with steady paid traffic and a working list.

Everything in Foundation, plus:

  • Separate forms for paid and organic visitors, quiz or landing-page signups, and two form tests a month.
  • Eight flows, adding replenishment or subscription, win-back, sunset and VIP or back in stock.
  • Eight segmented campaigns a month.
  • SMS flows and campaigns, planned with email.
  • Subscriber and customer lists synced to Meta and Google for exclusions and lookalikes.
  • Email revenue by opt-in source, with a monthly call.

Spark System

$7,500 a month

For brands scaling paid that want email and paid run as one system.

Everything in Growth, plus:

  • Forms matched to each live paid campaign and offer, with up to four tests a month.
  • Welcome flows split by opt-in source, so the welcome continues the ad that earned the signup.
  • Twelve segmented campaigns a month, with A/B tests.
  • Weekly budget recommendations for paid, based on which sources bring buyers.
  • Ad briefs from the emails that win, and one calendar with the paid team.
  • A weekly paid and email readout, and a call every two weeks.

In every package

  • An account, forms and deliverability audit at the start.
  • Email copy and design.
  • Deliverability monitoring.
  • Everything built in your own Klaviyo account.

Priced separately

  • Your Klaviyo subscription, paid to Klaviyo.
  • SMS sending costs, paid to your SMS platform.
  • Custom photography or video.
  • Paid ad management. Meta ads management starts from $5,000 a month.

Is an email marketing agency the right call?

A good fit if

  • You buy steady traffic on Meta, Google or TikTok, and want more of it to stay.
  • You sell online through Shopify or a similar store, and use Klaviyo.
  • Email brings in less than it should next to what you spend on ads.
  • You want email judged on revenue, not open rates.

Not the right fit if

  • You don't have steady traffic to your site yet. Our Meta ads team can help with that first.
  • You only need a newsletter designed.
  • The offer or margin is the real problem. We'll say so, and the Funnel Reset may suit you better.

Weighing your options? Read how to choose an agency, the questions to ask before you hire one, or what ecommerce marketing agencies charge.

Questions about hiring an email marketing agency

How much does an email marketing agency cost?

Most email agencies charge a monthly retainer, priced on how many emails they send and how much of the strategy they own. At First Spark, email marketing runs from $2,500 to $7,500 a month in three packages: Foundation, Growth and Spark System. Your Klaviyo subscription and SMS sending costs are paid to those platforms directly.

What's a good opt-in rate for an ecommerce site?

Klaviyo tells brands to aim for a popup and flyout opt-in rate of about 3% or higher, measured as signups per form view. We treat that as the floor, not the goal. Working with us, Komuso's opt-in rate went from 2% to 6% and Kumori's from 4% to 10.8%.

Do you work in Klaviyo?

Yes. We build and run everything inside your own Klaviyo account, so the forms, flows, segments and data stay yours.

Do you run SMS too?

Yes. SMS flows and campaigns are included in the Growth and Spark System packages, planned alongside email so the two channels don't repeat each other. SMS sending costs are billed by your SMS platform.

Which matters more, flows or campaigns?

Both, but flows punch above their weight. Klaviyo's benchmarks show flows bring in nearly 41% of email revenue from just 5.3% of sends. We build the flows first, then plan campaigns around your launches, promotions and paid calendar.

How do you track email revenue by opt-in source?

Every signup is tagged with the channel, campaign and ad that brought the visitor, using the tracking tags on your ads, and that tag stays on the subscriber's profile. We then report revenue per subscriber by source, so you can see whether Meta, Google, TikTok or organic search brings the subscribers who actually buy.

Do you need to run our paid ads too?

No. Foundation and Growth work with any paid setup. Spark System is built to run alongside your paid ads, whether we manage them or your own team does. Either way, we share the opt-in source data and the budget recommendations that come from it.

Does email work for CPG brands sold mostly in retail?

Yes, for the products where direct sales make money. Email carries launches, bundles and subscriptions on your own site, and it gives you a customer list you own instead of one your retailers own.

Find out how much of your traffic you're keeping

Tell us about your brand, your list and your ad spend. We'll look at your forms, flows and sources and tell you where the revenue is leaking.